AI slop songs are flooding Spotify — and the most recent hit is by an indie rock band known as The Velvet Sunset. The monitor’s success has intensified the continuing debate on whether or not or not music streaming websites ought to label AI-generated songs.
The group has attracted 474,341 month-to-month listeners on Spotify in beneath a month. Its high monitor, “Mud on the Wind” — which sounds just like the 1977 Kansas hit “Mud within the Wind” — has been performed over 380,0006 occasions since its launch on June 20.
The Velvet Sunset was first flagged as probably AI-generated by Reddit customers, who identified some suspicious indicators.
A profile image that appears as if it was created by AI. An Instagram account crammed with photos of band members that look…bizarre. And a bio with a purported quote from Billboard journal saying their music appears like “the reminiscence of one thing you by no means lived, and someway makes it really feel actual” — a quote that seems to have by no means truly been printed.
The 💜 of EU tech
The newest rumblings from the EU tech scene, a narrative from our smart ol’ founder Boris, and a few questionable AI artwork. It is free, each week, in your inbox. Enroll now!
There’s additionally no on-line hint of the band’s members listed in its Spotify bio: “vocalist and mellotron sorcerer Gabe Farrow, guitarist Lennie West, bassist-synth alchemist Milo Rains, and free-spirited percussionist Orion ‘Rio’ Del Mar.”
But, there’s nothing on The Velvet Sunset’s Spotify web page to verify the band is AI-generated. Its tracks even appeared on some Redditors’ “Uncover Weekly” playlists, an in-app characteristic that recommends new songs to customers.
The Velvet Sunset can also be obtainable on Apple Music and Amazon Music. The one main streaming web site the place it’s flagged as probably AI-generated is Deezer.
Earlier this month, Deezer turned the primary music streaming service to start out tagging AI-generated content material. Its algorithm can determine artificially created songs made utilizing a number of common generative AI fashions, together with Suno and Udio, which flip primary textual content prompts into “music.”
Over 20,000 absolutely AI-generated tracks flood Deezer’s platform every day. In April, bot-made audio made up 18% of “whole uploaded content material” — nearly double the ten% determine the corporate shared in January.
One other common AI-generated band is The Satan Inside, featured on a latest episode of John Oliver’s Final Week Tonight, titled “AI Slop.”
The Satan Inside’s high monitor, “Bones within the River,” has racked up 1.6 million listens on Spotify because it was launched on Might 16. Curiously, the monitor has no credited creator beneath the platform’s “View credit” tab.
Nevertheless, on Deezer the identical tune is flagged as AI-generated and credited to László Tamási, a Hungarian musician recognized for being the drummer of Honky Crew, an electro‑swing band. It represents a uncommon named credit score for an AI-generated artist, who usually stay nameless. We’ve reached out to Tamási for remark and can replace this piece in the event that they reply.
Deezer is an outlier in its offensive on AI-generated music. Spotify has but to launch any equal detector software. It additionally hasn’t made any makes an attempt to label such content material, no less than not publicly. Different music streaming platforms, together with Apple Music, Amazon Music, and Tidal, have remained nearly mute on the subject.
It’s maybe unsurprising that common music streaming platforms are sitting on their fingers. There are at the moment no rules on the move of AI-generated songs, or a consensus on what makes them acceptable or not. Even Deezer is split.
“AI will not be inherently good or unhealthy, however we imagine a accountable and clear method is essential to constructing belief with our customers and the music trade, mentioned Alexis Lanternier, Deezer’s CEO, final week.
“We’re additionally clear in our dedication to safeguarding the rights of artists and songwriters at a time the place copyright legislation is being put into query in favour of coaching AI fashions.”.
Final 12 months, a bunch of US document labels sued Suno and Udio, alleging copyright infringement on a “huge scale.” Nevertheless, the 2 corporations declare that coaching their fashions on copyrighted music falls beneath “honest use,” a frequent defence from AI companies.
