Hydrogen Mobility vs. Platinum Actuality

Help CleanTechnica’s work by a Substack subscription or on Stripe.

Alstom’s hydrogen prepare experiment has hit the buffers once more, with operators in Germany reverting to diesel as a result of alternative gasoline cells aren’t obtainable. Solely 4 of the 14 Cascadia trains Decrease Saxony bought are in operation. It’s tempting to dismiss this as a easy provide chain hiccup, however the issue runs deeper. Following the thread again reveals not solely the weak point of hydrogen in transportation but additionally a structural materials constraint that makes it even much less viable.

The Coradia iLint trains had been at all times meant to be a flagship for hydrogen mobility. They use gasoline cells provided by Cummins, constructed out of its Hydrogenics legacy in Canada and Europe. Every prepare carries two modules rated at about 200 kW every. Gasoline cells of that scale require 0.4 to 0.6 grams of platinum per kilowatt to realize the sturdiness demanded in rail service. That works out to about 0.2 kg of platinum per prepare. At immediately’s costs, that prices about $8,700, round 5% of the price of the gasoline cell. It sounds small till you set it in opposition to world manufacturing.

On the coronary heart of each PEM gasoline cell sits a skinny membrane coated with platinum, and its function is each easy and irreplaceable. Platinum acts because the catalyst that splits incoming hydrogen molecules into protons and electrons. The protons migrate by the membrane whereas the electrons are compelled round an exterior circuit, producing usable electrical energy. On the opposite aspect of the membrane, platinum once more makes the response attainable by dashing up the sluggish course of of mixing oxygen, protons, and electrons into water. These two reactions are basic to the system, and platinum’s distinctive floor chemistry permits them to occur at sensible charges and with the required sturdiness. With out platinum, the cell both fails to run effectively or falls aside too shortly. That catalytic operate is why each gram of platinum in a gasoline cell stack is indispensable, and why gasoline cells can not escape their dependence on a scarce and risky metallic.

The platinum market produces about 250 to 280 tons per 12 months. Roughly a 3rd goes into automotive catalysts, primarily for diesel automobiles and vehicles. One other quarter goes into jewellery. Industrial catalysts in refining and chemical compounds take up near a fifth. Glass and electronics take a smaller share. Gasoline cells and electrolysers collectively barely register at 1 or 2 tons a 12 months.

In catalytic converters for automobiles and vehicles, platinum is likely one of the metals that makes trendy combustion tolerable underneath air high quality guidelines. When exhaust gases go away the engine, they carry unburned hydrocarbons, carbon monoxide, and nitrogen oxides. Platinum gives energetic websites on its floor that break down these pollution by redox reactions on the excessive temperatures of the exhaust stream. Hydrocarbons and carbon monoxide are oxidized into carbon dioxide and water, whereas nitrogen oxides are lowered into nitrogen. Platinum works in live performance with palladium and rhodium, however in diesel engines platinum is the simplest catalyst due to the cooler and oxygen-rich exhaust. The finely dispersed platinum particles can face up to the thermal biking and chemical poisons that may destroy lesser supplies. With out platinum, diesel engines couldn’t meet emissions laws, which is why automakers purchase it at nearly any worth and why the demand from this sector dominates world consumption.

In refineries, platinum is the quiet workhorse of the catalytic reforming models that flip low-value naphtha into high-octane gasoline and feedstocks for petrochemicals. Platinum atoms dispersed on alumina help surfaces present energetic websites the place hydrocarbon molecules are rearranged, dehydrogenated, or cyclized underneath managed warmth and strain. This not solely upgrades gasoline high quality by elevating the octane quantity but additionally generates streams of hydrogen gasoline that the refinery reuses in hydrocracking and desulfurization. Platinum’s stability underneath harsh chemical and thermal situations is crucial, since these reactors run repeatedly for months at a time and downtime prices tens of millions. Whereas small quantities of rhenium or tin are sometimes added to tune efficiency, platinum stays the irreplaceable core of the catalyst mattress. With out it, the refining system that underpins each fuels and petrochemicals would seize up, which is why this sector treats platinum as an absolute necessity fairly than a discretionary expense.

South Africa provides about 70 p.c of mined platinum. Its mining sector is suffering from electrical energy shortages, floods, strikes, and political bottlenecks. Recycling provides solely a fraction and has fallen to its lowest degree in over a decade. The result’s a platinum market that’s undersupplied by almost 1,000,000 ounces per 12 months, which is about 31 tons. Costs have climbed to eleven-year highs, and lease charges spiked to ranges extra acquainted in distressed bond markets.

Recycling needs to be the strain valve for a constrained platinum market, however in apply restoration charges are low and risky. Most platinum recycling comes from end-of-life catalytic converters, the place the dense ceramic monoliths will be processed to reclaim the dispersed metallic. Even there, assortment inefficiencies, export restrictions, and processing bottlenecks imply massive fractions by no means make it again into the provision chain. In different functions like gasoline cells, electronics, and glass tools, restoration is even worse as a result of the platinum is both too finely distributed, too contaminated, or uneconomic to extract. The result’s that annual recycling contributes solely a small fraction of the roughly 250 tons of platinum demand, and volumes have been falling, not rising. That leaves major mining in South Africa and Russia to hold the load, which magnifies provide danger and retains gasoline cells uncovered to the volatility of a skinny and fragile market.

If you have a look at which industries are keen to pay most for platinum, gasoline cells come final. Automakers pays no matter it takes to fulfill emissions laws. Refineries can not function with out platinum catalysts and day by day offline prices tens of millions. Specialty glass and electronics producers haven’t any alternative materials for his or her high-temperature platinum instruments. Jewellery consumption is elastic, so it falls away when costs climb, liberating up some provide for industries that can’t do with out. Hydrogen gasoline cells sit on the finish of this queue, with restricted volumes and prospects delicate to price.

That is the place the weak point of hydrogen in transportation turns into clear. Batteries require metals as effectively, however there’s a variety of decisions. Nickel and cobalt will be averted solely by shifting to LFP chemistry, which is already mainstream in China and more and more within the west. Lithium itself will be substituted in lots of functions with sodium-ion, which is now in industrial manufacturing. Manganese and iron are considerable. In batteries there are trade-offs, however there is no such thing as a single non-substitutable metallic whose absence ends the know-how. In PEM gasoline cells platinum is that single level of failure.

Hydrogen for transportation was already deprived by poor power effectivity, excessive operational prices, larger infrastructure prices, and lack of market traction in comparison with batteries. The platinum provide constraint makes it worse. Each further megawatt of gasoline cell capability consumes extra of a scarce metallic that different industries will at all times outbid hydrogen for. Scaling hydrogen mobility solely deepens the reliance on a uncooked materials with no substitute, restricted suppliers, and power deficits.

Transit operators which have bought hydrogen bus fleets are going to be operating into this very same downside within the coming months and years. Gasoline cells sometimes solely final 2-3 years per EU knowledge, and with platinum shortages, gasoline cell distributors will likely be struggling to provide replacements. Warranties are going to be problematic as effectively, with larger prices for warranties for brand spanking new buses.

Pivot desk of hydrogen transportation play standing by creator

That is simply extra of the massacre in hydrogen transportation this 12 months. I not too long ago up to date my monitoring spreadsheet of hydrogen transportation companies. 41 of the 164 have both gone out of enterprise or dropped hydrogen. At that, lots of the companies haven’t mentioned something about hydrogen not too long ago, and are probably doing quiet pivots away from it which is able to solely turn into evident later. I believe Alstom will likely be dropping hydrogen shortly.

The return of Decrease Saxony’s trains to diesel is symbolic. It reveals how fragile hydrogen mobility is when even a handful of trains can’t be stored in service due to lacking gasoline cells. The irony is that the extra the sector tries to scale, the sooner it runs into the platinum wall. Battery electrical trains are already widespread, cheaper to function, and freed from this constraint. The lesson is obvious. Hydrogen for transportation isn’t just an inefficient concept. It’s one which collides with the arduous geology of platinum provide, making it a lifeless finish. The way forward for transport is electrical and it’ll run on considerable supplies, not scarce catalysts.

Join CleanTechnica’s Weekly Substack for Zach and Scott’s in-depth analyses and excessive degree summaries, join our every day e-newsletter, and observe us on Google Information!