Attorneys are masters at arguing their instances, however what occurs when synthetic intelligence flips the narrative?
Our occupation trains us to advocate relentlessly. We will argue any place so convincingly that over time we begin believing each phrase we are saying. That superpower wins instances and shoppers. But inside our personal heads, it may well additionally lure us in tales that erode confidence, pressure relationships and gas burnout.
That is the place AI quietly enters the scene, not as a menace however as a mirror.
Case research No. 1: The boss vs. the visionary
One in all my shoppers was satisfied his boss was sabotaging him. He noticed himself because the strategist and big-picture thinker destined for management. His boss, in his view, was a micromanaging value cutter buried within the weeds.
I recommended a twist: Feed the scenario into ChatGPT however from the boss’s viewpoint.
The output flipped all the pieces. Instantly, he was not the ignored visionary. He was portrayed because the underperformer who was immune to suggestions, fast guilty and failing to ship. It was uncomfortable to learn, however it shifted his mindset. He walked into his subsequent assembly seeing not an adversary however a supervisor responding to his personal blind spots. That reframing modified the dialog from confrontation to collaboration.
Case research No. 2: The crusader vs. the group
One other shopper felt vilified by her group. In her thoughts, she was the principled whistleblower who was standing up for what was proper whereas others stayed silent. We ran the identical train and requested AI to put in writing the story from the group’s perspective.
The narrative that got here again was sobering. She was portrayed as disruptive, uncollegial and unwilling to work inside established channels. It was not the reality, however it was a model value inspecting. Studying her story within the group’s voice revealed why her message, although legitimate, was falling flat. She adjusted her tone, timing and alliances, and the identical leaders who as soon as resisted her concepts started to pay attention.
The hidden superpower of AI for attorneys
Neither AI output was excellent. Neither was proper. However each supplied one thing extra worthwhile than validation: readability. These shoppers found that perspective-taking is just not give up; it’s technique. It delivers:
• Perspective insurance coverage towards blind spots
• Confidence resets earlier than troublesome conversations
• More healthy boundaries by processing narratives exterior midnight rumination
• Profession readability by understanding how others would possibly see us
When used on this means, AI turns into an empathy engine that helps attorneys study the assumptions behind their arguments and anticipate how these arguments land.
Past effectivity: Constructing AI-resilient attorneys
Most conversations about AI in legislation concentrate on pace: quicker analysis, faster drafting and streamlined billing. Effectivity issues. But the way forward for legislation will belong not solely to those that automate however to those that combine humanity with know-how.
AI-resilient attorneys know easy methods to:
• Use AI to problem their very own narratives as a substitute of reinforcing them
• Strengthen emotional intelligence and confidence via reflection
• Talk AI use transparently to construct belief with shoppers and colleagues
That is skilled improvement for the age of algorithms. It doesn’t substitute judgment; it sharpens it.
Privateness and ethics: Guardrails for curiosity
Each innovation brings warning. When experimenting with AI, attorneys should defend confidentiality as fastidiously as another shopper information. Public AI instruments ought to be handled like open boards, not closed recordsdata.
A couple of sensible guardrails embrace:
• Anonymizing inputs by eradicating shopper names, case particulars and figuring out info.
• Utilizing enterprise or personal fashions that don’t retailer or prepare in your prompts.
• Making use of the identical skilled accountability lens you’d use with any vendor; if you wouldn’t share it in an elevator, don’t paste it into ChatGPT.
• Documenting your course of when utilizing AI for perception or drafting. Transparency builds belief.
Dealt with thoughtfully, these instruments can co-exist with our moral duties and even strengthen them by encouraging attorneys to suppose extra critically earlier than they converse or ship.
Why it issues
Essentially the most harmful story a lawyer will ever inform is the one they by no means query. AI makes questioning unavoidable.
By inviting a second and generally uncomfortable perspective, we commerce certainty for perception. That’s the place development occurs. Attorneys who study to make use of AI not as a shortcut however as a self-check will discover themselves clearer, calmer and simpler advocates.
AI is not going to make us much less human. Used nicely, it’ll make us extra self-aware.
Brooke Loesby is a former BigLaw lawyer and the founding father of Legislation Life Coach Inc. She helps attorneys redefine success via profession technique, management teaching and well-being initiatives.
ABAJournal.com is accepting queries for authentic, considerate, nonpromotional articles and commentary by unpaid contributors to run within the Your Voice part. Particulars and submission pointers are posted at “Your Submissions, Your Voice.”
This column displays the opinions of the creator and never essentially the views of the ABA Journal—or the American Bar Affiliation.
