Ask any first-time purchaser, younger household, or downsizing pensioner what’s stopping them from shifting residence and also you’ll hear the identical reply: Stamp Responsibility Land Tax (SDLT). This as soon as marginal transaction value has developed right into a structural obstacle to the UK housing market, throttling mobility, discouraging motion, and stifling productiveness and financial development.
Let’s begin with the numbers. SDLT receipts reached £11.6 billion in 2022-23, practically double what they have been a decade in the past. This has come not from a booming market, however from bracket creep; as home costs rise, extra consumers are pushed into greater tax bands.
In London, the place the common home value is £564,000, even modest household houses incur hefty SDLT fees. A household upgrading to a £1.2 million residence, a typical four-bedroom home in Zones 2-4, faces a tax invoice of £61,250 earlier than a single field is packed.
This value has a chilling impact. In 2023, simply 1.01 million transactions befell, down from 1.2-1.3million pre-pandemic, and the bottom since 2012. A 2017 LSE report concluded that SDLT is a serious deterrent to transactions. In 2015, following the Conservative authorities’s SDLT overhaul, transaction volumes fell notably: whole gross sales in England and Wales dropped 11%, whereas Prime Central London declined 17% in comparison with 2014. Individuals are trapped as a result of they can not justify the SDLT value.
Younger consumers are hit hardest. Regardless of schemes like Assist to Purchase, many first-time consumers face the double problem of excessive deposits and SDLT. Those that scrape collectively a deposit discover themselves unable to afford the tax hit required to climb the ladder. Successive governments pledge to assist “era hire” but enable SDLT coverage to entice them.
It’s not simply the younger that suffer. Older owners, typically asset-rich however income-poor, wish to downsize and unencumber household houses however discover themselves penalised for doing so.
The broader financial affect is equally troubling. The housing market is a vital enabler of labour mobility. When folks can transfer simply, they take new jobs, begin households, develop companies. SDLT disincentivises this.
A 2017 LSE examine discovered that for each 1% enhance in SDLT, there’s a 17-20% lower within the chance of a family shifting. We’ve designed a tax that penalises dynamism.
SDLT additionally distorts the place folks reside. It incentivises staying in unsuitable houses, too small for rising households or too massive for ageing singles, merely to keep away from the tax. This creates gross misallocation of housing inventory in a rustic already struggling power scarcity.
While income from property taxes is essential for our economic system, SDLT is an inefficient manner of elevating it. It punishes transactions reasonably than possession. It penalises the behaviour we must always encourage: shifting, downsizing, and releasing housing inventory.
Merely altering charges received’t repair this. In its present kind, SDLT is regressive and outdated. SDLT ought to be abolished fully. Income ought to as an alternative get replaced by a reformed and fairer Council Tax – launched in 1993, primarily based on 1991 property costs and never reassessed since – to replicate present values.
This might be extra progressive, inserting the burden on these with the broadest shoulders while sustaining income and eradicating present market friction.
In the end, a dynamic housing market fuels consumption, employment, building and financial development. Most significantly, it’s about lives on maintain: the younger household with no second bed room, the retiree dealing with a £90,000 tax penalty to downsize, the employee turning down a job as a result of shifting home is simply too costly.
Stamp responsibility works towards all of them. Abolition isn’t simply fascinating; it’s an financial and social necessity.
Alex Michelin is founder and CEO of Valouran, a property improvement agency primarily based in London.
Rightmove urges brokers to share concepts on stamp responsibility reform
