Ethics
Choose recuses himself after ‘impulsive remark from the bench’ about capturing attorneys
Choose J. Layne Smith of Florida’s Second Judicial Circuit has apologized and recused himself from an property battle after telling attorneys within the case that he “want to inform the deputy to tug his gun and shoot all three of you.” (Picture from Florida’s Second Judicial Circuit)
A choose in Wakulla County, Florida, has apologized and recused himself from an property battle after telling attorneys within the case that he “want to inform the deputy to tug his gun and shoot all three of you.”
Choose J. Layne Smith of Florida’s Second Judicial Circuit advised the Tallahassee Democrat that he made “an impulsive remark from the bench that was unprofessional and out of character.” Smith mentioned he “didn’t actually imply the remark and instantly mentioned so.”
Smith advised the Tallahassee Democrat that he apologizes to the general public and the attorneys and has self-reported his conduct to judicial self-discipline officers, based on the Tallahassee Democrat (right here and right here) and Law360.
In keeping with a transcript, Smith mentioned: “I want to inform the deputy to tug his gun and shoot all three of you, so far as my degree of frustration. I actually don’t need him to try this. However, guys, for crying out loud, what is that this, the Keystone Cops, simply not very humorous?”
After the comment, the court docket reporter “motioned to point she was within the potential line of fireside and gave the impression to be indicating she desired to not be shot,” based on a recusal movement filed Oct. 1 by attorneys David A. Kemp and Stephen G. Webster.
Kemp’s and Webster’s movement mentioned Smith made “demeaning and insulting remarks to counsel” all through the Sept. 23 listening to. Their movement mentioned Smith “didn’t evaluation or genuinely take into account” a movement for sanctions filed by Kemp and Webster towards the legal professional for the opposing social gathering.
The opposing social gathering didn’t present up on the show-cause listening to, and Smith “turned visibly annoyed and blamed counsel,” significantly Kemp and Webster, the movement mentioned. The choose was unsuitable, nevertheless, as a result of the sheriff’s workplace was purported to serve the order, the movement mentioned.
Kemp advised Law360 in a press release that the choose ought to have recused from all instances that he and Webster had earlier than the choose, not simply the instances involving the property battle.
“Given the choose’s apparent bias and animosity in direction of me, it will be unfair to my shoppers to seem on their behalf in entrance of Choose Smith, and in consequence, I’m now compelled to show away potential shoppers in my dwelling county the place I’ve practiced for nearly 20 years,” Kemp advised the publication.
The opposing lawyer, Danny Phillips, advised the Tallahassee Democrat that he laughed when Smith commented about capturing the attorneys.
“The assertion itself, for those who have a look at it in isolation, one … may not must say that,” Phillips advised the publication. “However whenever you take it in context, on this case, is the choose actually going to have the deputy stroll outdoors and put down three attorneys? He was actually simply expressing his dissatisfaction.”
Write a letter to the editor, share a narrative tip or replace, or report an error.
