Freedom Of Speech And The Case Of The Homicidal Hoagie

Help CleanTechnica’s work by way of a Substack subscription or on Stripe.

If you happen to have been to gather all of the court docket instances that cope with the precise of free speech as contained within the First Modification of the US Structure, they’d fill dozens of volumes — perhaps even lots of. The truth that it’s set forth within the First Modification suggests the individuals who wrote it thought it was fairly damned necessary. A few of these instances have discovered that conduct could be protected speech, corresponding to gesticulating with varied hand gestures to different drivers to point out you have got a low opinion of their driving abilities.

Final week, the alleged president had a mind fart that induced him to ship federal troops to Washington, DC, ostensibly to curb an alleged crime wave within the US Capitol. That motion rubbed one man, Charles Dunn, the fallacious method. On August 10, 2025, Dunn determined to train his proper of free speech by hurling epithets at a number of of the federal brokers. In accordance with The Guardian, authorities declare that Dunn pointed his finger in an officer’s face and yelled, “Fuck you! You fucking fascists! Why are you right here? I don’t need you in my metropolis,” earlier than “winding his arm again and forcefully throwing sub-style sandwich” at an officer. A video of the incident is beneath.

[A hoagie, for those who are unfamiliar with the term, is a sandwich such as you might get from Subway or Jersey Mike’s. It is often called a sub because it resembles a submarine in appearance, unless you find yourself in certain parts of southern New England, where it is known as a grinder — for reasons now lost in the mists of history.]

Actions As Speech

US Lawyer Basic Pam Bondi is having none of such boorish conduct. She shortly noticed to it that Dunn was charged with a felony — hurling a hoagie that bounced off the bullet proof vest worn by one of many officers. Bondi snarled, “If you happen to contact any legislation enforcement officer, we’ll come after you. I simply discovered that this defendant labored on the Division of Justice — NO LONGER. Not solely is he FIRED, he has been charged with a felony. That is an instance of the Deep State we’ve been up in opposition to for seven months as we work to refocus DOJ. You’ll NOT work on this administration whereas disrespecting our authorities and legislation enforcement.”

Good gracious, Pammy, take a breath, will ya? Ought to Dunn have thrown a sandwich on the officer? After all not. That was silly. However to conflate his motion with the “Deep State” is simply ridiculous and an instance of the hysteria that’s the hallmark of this failed administration. Due to his lapse of judgement, this misguided particular person is now unemployed with no strategy to pay his hire or mortgage. Any property he could have will quickly go to pay an legal professional, and if Bondi has her method, he’ll spend years in solitary confinement at a Supermax jail, surrounded by the toughest of arduous instances.

To say Dunn regrets ever shopping for that hoagie might be a gross understatement. However what of the officers’ response? Was it proportional to the offense? Regulation enforcement officers have a tough job. They need to cope with criminals, certain, however in addition they need to cope with individuals below excessive bodily and emotional stress. I’m not a psychologist, nor have I ever performed one on TV, but it surely appears fairly clear from the video that Dunn was having a really unhealthy day. But the response of the federal brokers appears to be out of all proportion to the offense of hurling a homicidal hoagie of their course.

MAGA Thoughts Virus

For individuals who could not know, Bondi is a poster youngster for the type of MAGA thoughts virus that has swept the nation, a standpoint that permits individuals just like the so-called Vice President to allege with a straight face that Haitians are consuming the pets of individuals in Springfield, Ohio. It permits a sitting president to say with out proof that Washington, DC, and Los Angeles are crime ridden cities when in truth the proof clearly reveals that crime in each locations is at or close to a 30-year low.

Bondi first ran for legal professional normal within the state of Florida in 2010, the place her nomination was boosted by an endorsement by former Alaska Governor Sarah Palin and Fake Information character Sean Hannity. In accordance with Wikipedia, she was the lead legal professional in a lawsuit that sought to overturn the Inexpensive Care Act. She additionally has a historical past of opposing same-sex marriage and LGBTQ rights. In different phrases, she is MAGA by way of and thru, which raises an attention-grabbing level.

MAGA is all about outrage. The putative president spends each waking hour speaking about how persecuted he’s. Fake Information relies on feeding the sense of shock over the truth that white males in America need to share the nation with others. Rupert Murdoch has proven there are fortunes to be made by peddling hatred by some human beings in opposition to different human beings, which results in this query: Why is there no corresponding media presence for progressives?

Emotion Sells

The reply could be present in understanding the primary precept of gross sales, which is that individuals purchase on emotion and justify their choices later with details. Rush Limbaugh, Fake Information, Reality Social, The Each day Caller, Breitbart Information, and their ilk all are promoting emotion. Details and rational thought are nowhere to be discovered. However the lifeblood of all such enterprises is promoting {dollars}. Advertisers solely rely “eyeballs” — how many individuals are seeing the adverts they pay for. Within the battle between emotion and details, emotion is the clear winner.

Progressives concentrate on details — what number of cubic yards of glaciers are melting every single day, what number of sq. miles of forest have burned since yesterday, what the extent of carbon dioxide is on the Mauna Loa Observatory, how many individuals are coated by Medicaid at any given time. Advertisers received’t pay to advertise such cerebral pronouncements that depend on motive.

Free speech means progressives can discuss their product all they need, however nobody can pay the slightest consideration if their message is stripped of all emotion. Within the battle for the hearts and minds of America, progressives are dropping primarily as a result of the individuals who select to talk for them are previous. Now don’t get me fallacious. I’m previous — sufficiently old to know that if I have been the spokesperson for progressive causes on digital platforms, most viewers would dismiss what I’ve to say out of hand.

Who needs to take heed to what Chuck Schumer, or Nancy Pelosi, or Hillary Clinton, or Oprah need to say? These persons are previous. In comparison with the brilliant faces on Fake Information, they’re historical. No surprise individuals go to sleep after they converse. Marshall McLuhan informed us “the medium is the message,” and in the present day the medium is visible. It’s visceral.  And till progressives determine leverage platforms which might be visible and visceral, they’ll proceed to lose.

Pretty Unbalanced

Walter Cronkite was an enormous within the information enterprise 50 years in the past. His opinions formed the nationwide dialog. When he got here out in opposition to the Vietnam Warfare, Nixon’s advisers knew the sport was over. “If we’ve misplaced Cronkite, we’ve misplaced the nation,” they informed the president. Right now, Cronkite couldn’t get a job as a newsman at a small city newspaper.

Motive and rationality are so yesterday. The turning level for Al Gore was not whether or not he wore a heat and fuzzy sweater, it was the gangs of disruptive individuals the Republicans flew to Florida from throughout the nation to wave their preprinted “Sore Loserman” indicators and scream about stealing votes. Hillary didn’t lose due to her emails; she misplaced as a result of the producers of the debates allowed the Republican challenger to wander into her house and glower at her, a picture that confirmed Clinton as powerless and unable to regulate the state of affairs.

Democrats spend extra time destroying their very own than attempting to win elections. They demonize AOC and her friends as “the squad” and are outraged {that a} Muslim is their main candidate for mayor of New York Metropolis. Till they discover a message that resonates with individuals — and study to promote their product — they’ll proceed to lose election after election. Free speech could also be free, however to get your message throughout, it’s essential appeal to “eyeballs.” The reactionaries have discovered how to do this very properly. Progressives assume they’re nonetheless again within the Tammany Corridor period, when voters did what the celebration informed them to.

America wants progressive voices, not celebration bosses. Dropping is changing into a behavior. It’s time for them to learn to promote themselves to voters or threat changing into fully irrelevant. Irrelevancy is the one factor the hunt for a sustainable Earth can’t face up to.