Michael Mann To Invoice Gates: What World Are You Dwelling In?

Assist CleanTechnica’s work by a Substack subscription or on Stripe.

Invoice Gates photos himself as a expertise and system innovator. In October, the billionaire philanthropist recontextualized local weather motion, world well being, and growth as mutually unique and in competitors with one another prematurely of the worldwide local weather summit, COP30. Together with his standing as one of many authentic Silicon Valley tech bros, Gates wrote a memo that minimized the inevitable penalties of local weather change, saying, “It won’t result in humanity’s demise. Individuals will be capable to dwell and thrive in most locations on Earth for the foreseeable future.” Local weather scientist Michael Mann disagrees heartily.

“What world is Gates residing in?” Mann asks. “The concept that local weather motion should come on the expense of efforts to handle human well being is a provable fallacy.”

A Pre-COP30 Memo with Ripple Results

Maybe you acknowledge the identify Michael Mann however can’t retrieve why? Envision the enduring “hockey stick” picture that demonstrated the unprecedented nature of latest, human-caused warming from the burning of fossil fuels. Mann is the one who created the analogy so on a regular basis individuals like me and you’d have a greater grasp of the local weather disaster.

However Invoice Gates doesn’t need to settle for the devastating nuances of a warming world. As an alternative, he boasts about small and relatively tenuous technological fixes. Mann argues that Gates’ 17-page memo dismisses the seriousness of the local weather disaster.

Right here’s the factor, Invoice Gates. There isn’t a ‘patch’ for the local weather disaster. And there’s no strategy to reboot the planet when you crash it. The one protected and dependable approach out when you end up in a local weather gap is to cease digging—and burning—fossil fuels.

Gates speaks from a place of “vanity,” based on Mann, through which the Microsoft founder truly appears to suppose “one thing as conceptually primary as decomposing carbon emissions right into a product of constituent phrases had by no means been tried earlier than.”

As Gates downplays the function of unpolluted power and speedy decarbonization, Mann advises us that, “for many who have been following Gates on local weather for a while, his so-called sudden ‘pivot’ isn’t actually a ‘pivot’ in any respect. It’s a logical consequence of the misguided path he’s been headed down for effectively over a decade.” What Gates paints over is his investments in fossil fuel-based infrastructure (ie. pure gasoline with carbon seize and enhanced oil restoration) by his enterprise capital group, Breakthrough Power Ventures. He has financed what he positions as worthwhile geoengineering interventions like spraying large quantities of sulfur dioxide into the stratosphere to dam out daylight and funky the planet.

Gates chooses to focus on sectors that face quite a few decarbonizing challenges, like metal or air journey, as an alternative of acknowledging the power infrastructure that may readily be decarbonized now. He favors hypothetical new power tech, together with modular nuclear reactors that Mann says “couldn’t probably be scaled up over the time-frame through which the world should transition off fossil fuels.”

Gates’ “newest missive,” Michael Mann states, “performs like a sport of local weather change-diminishing bingo.”

Duh, Poverty and Illness are a Subset of Local weather Change

In his memo, Gates asserts that local weather activists ought to decelerate their concentrate on near-term emissions targets — what he refers to as a “doomsday outlook” — and, as an alternative, work towards bettering life in a warming world. He insists that “efforts to battle local weather change detract from efforts to handle human well being threats.”

Michael Mann’s new e book, Science Beneath Siege, co-authored with public well being scientist Peter Hotez, explains that local weather and human well being are inseparable, with local weather change fueling the unfold of lethal illness. Mann refutes Gates’ assertion that “the poor and downtrodden have extra urgent issues.” As an alternative, information constantly exhibits the alternative: it’s the impoverished and powerless who possess the fewest means to battle local weather change “as a result of they’ve the least wealth and resilience,” says Mann.

Sure, poverty and illness should be addressed systemically as primary human rights, however Mann argues that addressing world warming and world well being isn’t a zero-sum sport. As an alternative, local weather change intensifies pandemics and vector-borne ailments, comparable to malaria. “Each fraction of a level of warming we stop means great quantities of averted injury,” Mann clarifies.

However the “’tech bro’-centered considering so prevalent right now in public environmental discourse” masks the significance of unpolluted power. Gates is complicit, embracing a “constant sample of downplaying clear power whereas selling doubtful and doubtlessly harmful technofixes through which he’s typically personally invested.”

Such technofixes for the local weather, Mann continues, “lead us down a harmful street, each as a result of they displace far safer and extra dependable choices—specifically the clear power transition—and since they supply an excuse for business-as-usual burning of fossil fuels.”

Why decarbonize, he parodies, if we will simply resolve the issue with a “patch” later? “What might probably go improper?” Mann laughs. “And hey, if we screw up this planet, we’ll simply geoengineer Mars. Proper Elon?”

Gates has insisted a “premium” have to be paid for a clear power buildout. Surely, clear power “has a decrease levelized value than fossil fuels or nuclear and deflected the questions with advert hominem swipes,” Mann reminds us.

The Peril of Specializing in Fossil Fuels

Mann acknowledges that “we’re definitely dealing with adversity on the subject of a clear power transition within the US proper now, what with the present administration and congressional Republicans working collectively to advance what’s primarily a fossil-fuel agenda.” Nevertheless, Gates fails to establish the actual “miracle inside our grasp.

It’s known as the solar, and wind, and geothermal, and power storage expertise. Actual world options exist now and are simply scalable with the fitting investments and priorities. The obstacles aren’t technological. They’re political.

Gates appears to be feeding right into a false impression that Biden administration Inflation Discount Act advantages to pink states would affect politicians to embrace each extra clear power initiatives. “We’re studying that it’s much more essential to (politicians) to do the bidding of the highly effective vested pursuits which have taken over,” Mann describes, “particularly the fossil gas trade, which has a stranglehold over right now’s Republican Get together.”

Has Gates succumbed to a actuality that rising world temperatures are inevitable? Large Media appears to be following his lead. “The legacy media is outwardly extra within the local weather musings of an erstwhile PC mogul,” Mann muses, “than a sober evaluation by the world’s main local weather scientists.”

As an alternative, Michael Mann calls out Gates and argues that there’s just one strategy to resolve the local weather disaster. “Science is not only underneath siege — it’s being weaponized,” he delineates, pointing to coordinated campaigns that distort info and sow doubt for political and monetary achieve.

Perhaps—simply perhaps—we’ve discovered an essential lesson right here: The answer to the local weather disaster isn’t going to come back from the fairy-dust-sprinkled flying unicorns which might be the ‘benevolent plutocrats.’ They don’t exist. The answer goes to have to come back from everybody else, utilizing each software at our disposal to push again in opposition to an ecocidal agenda pushed by plutocrats, polluters, petrostates, propagandists, and too typically now, the press.

Mann, as an alternative, presents a strategic roadmap for reclaiming scientific integrity, emphasizing the facility of training, transparency, and civic engagement. He has made basic contributions to local weather science like the approaching and going of ice ages; the function of each pure and human drivers on noticed local weather variability and alter,;the affect that local weather change on excessive climate occasions comparable to warmth waves, droughts, wildfires and floods; and the rising coastal risk from melting ice, growing sea degree, and better storms surges.

Gates has complimented Mann, acknowledging he “does superb work on local weather change.” He additionally accuses Mann of being “anti-innovation.” Nonetheless, Mann is engaged in in depth efforts to interact the general public on the defining difficulty and problem of local weather change, looking for to tell scientists, coverage makers, civic and environmental organizations and most people with primary data and understanding of Earth’s local weather.

I take into account myself privileged to have discovered myself able to affect the dialog about what’s arguably the best problem we face as a civilization.

Assets

• “About Michael E. Mann: Local weather scientist.” The Explorers Membership. 2025.
• “Invoice Gates’s local weather feedback are a harmful distraction.” Michael E. Mann. Nature. November 2025.
• “Michael Mann to Invoice Gates: You’ll be able to’t reboot the planet when you crash it.” Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists. October 31, 2025.
• Science Beneath siege: Tips on how to battle the 5 strongest forces that threaten our world. Michael E. Mann, Peter J. Hotez. 2025.
• “Three robust truths about local weather.” Invoice Gates. Gates Notes. October 28, 2025.