Pakistan’s LNG Retreat Alerts Bother for Canada’s Export Ambitions

Help CleanTechnica’s work by way of a Substack subscription or on Stripe.

Pakistan’s request that Qatar divert or promote 24 contracted LNG cargoes in 2026 is a pointy sign for each nation that also assumes LNG demand will rise for many years. Pakistan dedicated to long-term LNG contracts when its planners believed energy demand would develop steadily and imported gasoline would fill the hole between home gasoline decline and rising consumption.

The nation is now coping with a special actuality. Pakistan added roughly 17 GW of photo voltaic in 2024, which I wrote on the time was one of the vital dramatic single-year shifts in any rising market energy system. The size of that buildout modified Pakistan’s electrical energy combine in ways in which planners had not anticipated. Photo voltaic pushed down daytime gasoline era, decreased the variety of hours gasoline era crops operated, and uncovered long-term LNG contracts to monetary stress. The nation’s fast transfer towards low-cost home renewables was not pushed by local weather coverage. It was pushed by affordability, vitality safety, and the necessity to escape value volatility. The choice to dump two dozen LNG cargoes is per the route set in that earlier evaluation.

Grid-scale batteries are rising. Hydropower varies however can drop LNG use when water is on the market. Fuel-fired crops are operating fewer hours. Pakistan doesn’t want the LNG it promised to purchase and is attempting at hand the cargoes again earlier than they develop into monetary liabilities. This isn’t a quirk of 1 harassed economic system. It’s the first seen failure of a requirement mannequin that assumes Asia will take in LNG far into the longer term. Canada is getting ready to develop into a significant LNG exporter on the identical time the pillars of that demand mannequin are weakening. The query now could be what this implies for Canadian LNG megaprojects which can be getting into a market which seems to be much less secure by the month.

The core driver behind the drop in LNG demand is the fast world buildout of photo voltaic and battery storage. These two applied sciences minimize into the position of gasoline in electrical energy techniques. Mixed cycle gasoline generators used to offer regular baseload operation. Open cycle generators stuffed the peaks. Photo voltaic cuts the daytime peak of the load curve and makes noon gasoline era uncompetitive. Batteries replenish through the duck curve, present a part of the night peak and are increasing their working home windows. Fuel strikes from being a spine of the ability system to being a much less and fewer used peaking gasoline. This modifications the way in which LNG matches into nationwide vitality plans. In international locations with LNG import contracts, the fastened price of LNG turns into a burden when crops run fewer hours. The economics change shortly and governments start searching for methods to scale back publicity. Canada is constructing LNG export infrastructure for a world that’s utilizing extra renewable electrical energy and fewer imported gasoline. That disconnect is changing into clearer each quarter.

One strategy to see this shift is to take a look at the variety of LNG import terminals which have been cancelled, paused or deserted. Because the desk above, shortly assembled by me when contemplating this, and therefore probably containing inaccuracies, exhibits these terminals characterize future demand that was anticipated to justify new LNG export megaprojects. It’s just one% to five%, relying on the way you rely it, of world LNG import amenities, however for exporters projecting a development market, that contraction is important.

In South Asia, Pakistan’s deliberate terminals have stalled. Bangladesh cancelled its third floating storage and regasification unit (FSRU) and halted enlargement efforts. Sri Lanka cancelled an LNG undertaking backed by Japanese companions. India shelved a number of coastal LNG terminals, together with each Kakinada initiatives. The sample is analogous in Southeast Asia. Vietnam suspended or shelved a lot of its LNG terminal pipeline after adopting a long run energy plan that shifted towards photo voltaic, wind and storage. The Philippines accepted a number of LNG terminals however just one is operational and the remaining lack financing, clients or building momentum. Thailand has scaled again enlargement plans after seeing gasoline demand flatten. These cancelled terminals characterize the markets Canada anticipated to serve. The infrastructure just isn’t being constructed as a result of demand just isn’t robust sufficient to assist it.

The declines in LNG demand are sharper when wanting on the main Asian economies. China’s LNG imports fell by about 22% within the first half of 2025. The nation added extra photo voltaic in a single yr than the world added just a few years earlier. Giant scale battery storage is increasing. Home gasoline manufacturing and pipeline gasoline from Central Asia and Russia cut back the necessity for imported LNG. When hydro output is excessive and photo voltaic grows shortly, LNG imports fall. China has re exported cargoes as a substitute of consuming them. China is a major purchaser in some years and a marginal purchaser in others. This variability undermines the outdated assumption that China would steadily improve LNG consumption.

India exhibits the identical development. India’s LNG imports fell by about 9% within the first a part of 2025 on the again of a 34% decline in gasoline era. Photo voltaic buildout is accelerating. Monsoon seasons increase hydropower and cut back gasoline plant output. Value delicate industrial customers shift away from LNG when spot costs rise. India not too long ago resold a US LNG cargo to Europe as a result of home demand was not excessive sufficient to justify taking supply. Collectively China and India have been anticipated to anchor the subsequent twenty years of LNG demand. They’re now constructing electrical energy techniques that combine photo voltaic, wind, hydro and batteries with a lot much less dependence on imported gasoline.

Japan gives one other essential sign. Japan’s LNG imports have dropped as nuclear reactors restart and renewable electrical energy expands. Power effectivity has improved, decreasing complete demand. Japanese utilities have shifted from consuming LNG to reselling it. They use versatile contracts to purchase cargoes after which promote them on world markets when home demand is low. Long run LNG contracts used to anchor the worldwide market. Japan was the secure purchaser that made LNG export initiatives bankable. That position is disappearing as Japan reduces consumption and turns into a extra versatile participant in LNG buying and selling.

Europe has added one other strain level. A number of European LNG import terminals are operating at single digit utilisation. Germany’s Mukran terminal operated close to 5% within the first quarter of 2025. Greece’s Alexandroupolis FSRU operated at roughly 2% throughout its early interval on account of a technical failure and weak demand. France’s Le Havre FSRU has been principally idle and is being eliminated. Different European LNG terminals function nicely beneath capability. European gasoline demand has fallen on account of regular renewable development, extra warmth pumps and weaker industrial load. The LNG capability inbuilt response to the 2022 vitality disaster is excess of Europe presently wants. This underuse provides extra out there LNG to world markets and will increase competitors for the remaining demand in Asia.

These demand reductions arrive on the identical time that world LNG provide is increasing. Qatar is including main new capability from the North Area enlargement. The USA is bringing a big wave of latest liquefaction capability on-line between 2025 and 2028. Papua LNG, Mozambique and different initiatives are rising. Canada’s LNG Canada facility is getting into service and different export proposals are in varied phases of planning and evaluate. The provision curve is rising whereas demand is flattening. Oversupply is inevitable. Costs will stay underneath strain. Long run contracts shall be more durable to safe with out concessions on flexibility and pricing. The massive LNG provide wave is arriving simply because the renewable vitality buildout in Asia and Europe is decreasing the variety of hours gasoline crops function. This can be a structural mismatch that exporters will discover exhausting to handle.

Canada’s LNG export technique was constructed round the concept Asian consumers would wish extra LNG for many years. That expectation formed the event of LNG Canada in Kitimat and the subsequent wave of proposed amenities which can be a part of nationwide planning. LNG Canada alone locks in massive emissions if it operates at full output for many years. As I famous not too long ago, its complete emissions might attain greater than two billion tons of CO₂ equal over a fifty yr lifespan. You might have additionally written concerning the native impacts in Kitimat, together with flaring and air high quality points. The undertaking is positioned as each a nation constructing effort and an export engine. The issue is that it depends upon world LNG demand that not seems to be secure.

The following wave of Canadian LNG faces a fair harder market. Lots of the potential consumers that Canada focused are cancelling import terminals, decreasing LNG demand or reselling cargoes. Japan just isn’t a dependable sink for LNG. China and India are decreasing imports. South and Southeast Asia aren’t scaling LNG to the diploma anticipated. Europe is oversupplied and is working to scale back gasoline consumption over the long run. That leaves Canada competing in a crowded market with Qatar, the USA and different low price producers. Canada’s LNG manufacturing prices are greater than lots of its rivals. If world demand stays weak Canada might develop into a swing producer that adjusts provide to steadiness the market. That might imply decrease utilisation of export terminals and upstream belongings.

The Canadian authorities is attempting to steadiness LNG export enlargement with local weather targets. The contradiction is obvious. If world LNG demand grows sufficient to assist Canadian exports then world emissions outcomes are incompatible with acknowledged local weather targets. If world LNG demand stays flat or declines sufficient to satisfy local weather targets then Canadian LNG amenities face a excessive threat of low utilisation or stranded asset outcomes. The result’s a set of initiatives that wrestle to align with each financial and local weather targets. The extra photo voltaic and storage spreads throughout Asia the extra these contradictions come into focus.

Pakistan’s twenty 4 LNG cargoes are an early marker of a broader development. LNG demand is weakening throughout main consuming areas. Import infrastructure is being cancelled. Some import terminals that have been constructed solely a short while in the past are operating at very low utilisation. China and India have posted double digit drops in LNG imports within the first half of 2025. Japan is reselling LNG. Europe is overcapacity. Canada is getting into the LNG export market throughout a interval when renewable applied sciences are eroding the position of gasoline in electrical energy techniques. The LNG market is altering quicker than Canada’s planning cycle.