Recycling Lead-Acid Batteries Has Vital Well being Dangers

Help CleanTechnica’s work via a Substack subscription or on Stripe.

Recycling. We should always all do it at any time when attainable, however in actuality, it’s usually cheaper to mine new supplies than it’s to recapture and reuse those we have already got. One of many causes now we have single-use plastic bottles is as a result of gentle drink corporations and dairies discovered it was far cheaper to purchase billions of plastic containers than it was to gather, clear, and reuse glass bottles.

Opponents of electrical vehicles and renewable vitality work themselves right into a lather over the younger kids within the Democratic Republic of Congo who’re being poisoned whereas working in cobalt mines. Folks get all labored up about how sooner or later there will likely be thousands and thousands of tons of photo voltaic panels clogging up landfills and leaching dangerous chemical compounds into the soil. And don’t get them began on the stacks of damaged wind turbine blades piling up world wide!

Thankfully, recycling lithium-ion batteries is now a longtime answer, so the declare by some that EV house owners merely push their automobiles into the closest lake when the batteries die is now demonstrably false. Additionally, recycling wind turbine blades is changing into a viable enterprise as nicely.

Honestly, there are causes to be involved about these points. However the factor that rankles me is how these pious defenders of the atmosphere are so willfully blind to the hurt performed by just about each type of business endeavor. There are billions of discarded tires in dumps world wide. West Virginia and Kentucky have seen complete mountains eliminated and dumped into the valleys beneath to get on the coal buried beneath. Poisonous coal ash is piling up round coal-fired producing stations all world wide and leaching poisons into the atmosphere.

If you’re going to be a defender of the atmosphere, that’s great. However at the least be constant. Don’t go to city conferences to protest about wind generators should you aren’t going to push for an finish to all air pollution, not simply the sort you hear about on delinquent media or Fake Information. Hypocrisy is rampant on this house. We people have to acknowledge that we can’t deal with our planet as a communal rest room and count on to keep away from the diseases and illnesses that afflict us.

In latest many years, there was an explosion in miscarriages, beginning defects, autism, cancers, coronary heart illness, and respiratory illnesses. It’s disingenuous — and harmful — to put the blame on the doorstep of electrical vehicles or renewable vitality and ignore the opposite environmental harms which can be half and parcel of on a regular basis commerce. An ideal instance is the harm performed to people who find themselves concerned in recycling lead batteries.

Lead Recycling Is Dangerous To Folks

At present, there are about 1.6 billion automobiles on the earth, and just about each one in every of them has a lead-based battery onboard. Even electrical vehicles have them to function the low-voltage programs that function door locks and inside lights, though some corporations like Tesla are beginning to exchange them with lithium-ion batteries.

These batteries can have a helpful life of two to five years, however all of them must be changed sooner or later. What occurs to the previous ones when they’re not serviceable? They get melted all the way down to recuperate the lead in them, which may then be used to make new batteries. Within the US, that work usually will get outsourced to different international locations. In line with a latest report by the New York Instances, Nigeria is one nation that has a flourishing battery recycling sector. Mexico is one other.

It’s heavy, soiled work for many who have jobs within the trade. But it surely additionally takes a toll on the atmosphere. That shouldn’t be a shock to most folk. What could also be a shock, nevertheless, is how the auto trade has tried to deflect consideration away from the issue for many years. Identical to the tobacco and asbestos industries, automakers and their suppliers have gone to nice lengths to keep away from demanding that recycled lead be produced in a manner that’s environmentally secure and doesn’t make staff sick.

The Inexperienced Lead Initiative

“Annually, lead poisoning is estimated to kill greater than 1.5 million folks, most of them in creating international locations,” the New York Instances experiences. It says in 2005, Phillip Toyne, an Australian lawyer, warned auto trade executives the lead inside automobile batteries was poisoning folks. He had an answer — a program he referred to as Inexperienced Lead that will confirm which lead recycling operations have been working in an environmentally accountable style.

The Inexperienced Lead proposal was mentioned throughout the trade, however in the end the businesses determined to not embrace it. A evaluate of trade information and interviews with auto executives performed by the New York Instances confirmed that automakers and their suppliers have identified about the issue with lead recycling for nearly three many years.

“Again and again, automobile and battery producers opted to not act and blocked efforts to deal with the issue. When the world’s largest automobile corporations wrote their environmental insurance policies, they excluded lead. They did so whilst a patchwork of shoddy factories in Ghana, Nigeria and Tanzania offered extra lead for his or her batteries,” the Instances experiences claims.

Bernd Gottselig, a retired Ford govt who was concerned in talks about Inexperienced Lead, instructed the Instances that addressing lead air pollution and different environmental issues was “financially difficult” for the corporate. “A number of concepts would have required organising utterly new and distinctive provide chains,” he mentioned.

Michael Rae, who was engaged on a program to certify metals and minerals within the jewellery trade, was concerned in a few of these conferences about Inexperienced Lead. The issue was, if the businesses touted Inexperienced Lead, that will suggest there have been different types of lead that weren’t licensed as responsibly processed and that might pose a public relations dilemma for the businesses. “My recollection is that there was lively resistance from the motorcar trade to the thought of claiming ‘inexperienced lead’ due to the implication that there was ‘dangerous lead,’” Rae mentioned.

Politics Rears Its Ugly Head

Bob Holcombe is a former director with the Normal Companies Administration who was answerable for greater than 600,000 US authorities automobiles. Involved about extra stringent environmental rules relevant to motor automobiles, he contacted ASTM Worldwide and requested them for assist crafting requirements for battery recycling.

ASTM’s guidelines solely required a easy majority to type a committee, and anybody who attended a gathering might vote. In December 2012, the group was contemplating whether or not to ascertain a committee to look into the lead recycling problem. Stricter requirements would inevitably result in greater manufacturing prices and elevated scrutiny of automotive provide chains. The trade wished no a part of these new guidelines.

At the moment, Johnson Controls was the biggest producer of batteries. It despatched 50 representatives to the assembly. 30 extra got here from different battery corporations. Of the 98 folks within the room, 80 have been from corporations within the battery trade. “It was fairly clear within the room that we had gathered to do that after which Johnson Controls determined they didn’t need it,” mentioned James Meinert, who represented the Pure Assets Protection Council. The vote to type a committee failed.

Automobile Firms Look The Different Means

All main automobile corporations now determine minerals and metals which can be identified to hurt the atmosphere and human well being if they’re obtained irresponsibly. Lead just isn’t on a lot of these lists, the New York Instances investigation confirmed.

Hyundai maintains a listing of minerals which can be vital to the “future and atmosphere of mankind,” and requires its suppliers to acquire these minerals ethically. Normal Motors has positioned six metals underneath heightened scrutiny. Different corporations ignored the requests for info from the Instances or supplied bland statements about their commitments to purchase or recycle all merchandise responsibly.

Volvo and Mitsubishi mentioned they do record lead among the many metals they monitor. Nissan mentioned its coverage is to section out the usage of lead “the place technically possible.” In July, Ford launched its most up-to-date sustainability report, saying that it was “voluntarily holding itself accountable to a brand new degree of rigor. Provide chain transparency and human rights safety go hand in hand,” Ford wrote, however its report says nothing about lead.

Steven Younger, an industrial ecologist and professor on the College of Waterloo in Ontario instructed the New York Instances that corporations have been motivated by experiences of kid labor abuse within the DRC, the place a lot of the world’s cobalt is mined. “Some corporations mentioned, ‘Holy crap, we don’t need this in our provide chain. What can we do?’ I don’t suppose lead has had that second.”

The query is, why not?